Wednesday, May 10, 2017

Teaching Our Sons to Walk

There are few things that suck the joy from my soul more than talking on the phone. As an introvert in the cyber age, I find calls taxing, senseless even.

But I always take Robert's calls.

When his name popped up last week, I grabbed it. I was standing in the bathroom covering my dark circles, about to head out and tackle a couple of errands.

"Mom? Can I borrow twenty dollars?"

These calls are not outside the norm, but his heavy breathing was. I could tell he was running.

"I'm at my probation meeting and I left my money in my other pants. I'll hit you back later today. I promise. I got it. Can you please help?"

Of course I could.

"I'm almost there. I gotta hurry. My PO's gonna kill me if I take too long."


An hour earlier I had gone looking for my Bible and couldn't find it. I searched all of the usual places. Nightstand? Coffee table? My purse? No, no, no. I ran outside to the van, remembering my hands had been full the night before after Bible study. I had grabbed the empty soup pot, the giant bag of paper goods, and my purse, leaving the Bible on the middle console.

Now, it wasn't there.

I ran inside and called Cory to see if he had borrowed it. No, he didn't have it either.

It hit me that my Bible, with its cover split along the seams, held together by strips of tape, filled with notes and underlines and the picture of my friend out there somewhere strung out and chasing death, had been stolen.

Moving to the city hasn't cured us of leaving our doors unlocked, not even after having several things nabbed overnight - a power tool, a jar of change, a Red Robin gift card we were saving for a rainy day. The drill was the most expensive loss and in each case, it was easy to assume the taker needed whatever it was more than we did. We hardly gave it a second thought.

But my Bible? That one was both easier to swallow, and much, much harder.


I was still getting ready when he burst through the door, panting. He bent over at the waist to catch his breath, having run a mile from the courthouse to our front door - his front door, where he knows he never has to knock. He yelled back outside, "You can come in!" then looked at me and shrugged, "I guess he doesn't want to." I still have no idea who was out there, but it's not unusual for him to show up with extras.

We talked for a second about his meeting with his Probation Officer while he clutched the waistband of his baggy, black shorts so they wouldn't fall down around his ankles. Silently, I questioned his choice of attire for this meeting where he already knew he was in hot water. He could have at least tried, I judged.

He was upbeat that day, as usual. But lately, I've noticed a thin layer of paranoia skimming the surface of his mundane, and he's never been one to borrow trouble. It used to worry me, the way he seemed almost oblivious to this world he's very much in, whether he acknowledges it or not. There was the time he laughed it off when he was pulled over five times in one weekend for having a tail light out. He was proud of himself for willingly sitting on the curb while his car was searched without a cause or a warrant.

Last week, after complimenting my hair (just like Silas, he notices these things and I love him for it) he brought up a few stories that had been in the news. He talked politics, which almost never happens. He flexed his hands, open and shut, counting the years since he's been caught up in the system, "I've passed every drug test. I've done everything they want me to do. I just want to live."

Then he kissed my cheek like he always does, drew a sharp breath for the run back, and blew out the door. Ten seconds later, he bolted back in, guzzled a glass of water from the tap, and was gone again.


I grabbed my purse moments later and headed out to the van, wondering if I would drive past him and his friend, wondering how fast they ran. I wished I had thought it through and given them a ride.

My purse felt heavier than usual and I peeked inside. Right at the top of the stack of granola bars, chapsticks, earbuds, and old grocery lists sat my Bible. I still have no idea how I missed it when I had checked earlier.

Just as I hopped into the driver's seat, an unfamiliar Jeep with rusted wheel wells pulled up behind me, blocking my path. A stranger approached me, her face set and serious. I rolled my window down.

"Ma'am, are you missing anything from your van?"

I glanced behind me, thought about my Bible. How did she know? It took me a second to reconcile reality. Wait, no one took it. It's right here. 

"Nope," I smiled. "Why?"

"Well, we drove by a couple of minutes ago and saw some very suspicious activity outside your house."

I immediately knew where the conversation was going, but let her continue.

"Two guys were acting very suspicious." She paused, waiting for me to react. Leaning in closer, she lowered her voice, drawing out the next nine syllables. "They were African American."

I swallowed hard, held eye contact. "Yes," I said. "That was my son."


If she'd been seated on a ten-speed, her back-pedaling would have set her five miles North in no time flat. She apologized profusely, backing away from my van, ashen.

"They seemed fidgety" she stammered. "They were running."

"Right. They were late for a meeting." I hated myself for offering an explanation. I hated her for stopping. I hated the world, every shaded corner, every block where the truth has been twisted in knots.

Still, I knew her intentions weren't harmful.

I asked if she was a neighbor. I'd never seen her before, and there aren't many I don't at least recognize. I thought maybe she'd slipped under my radar, that she was actively involved here enough to at least think she knew the comings and goings of this place.

No. She was just passing through.

Over and over, she tripped on her own explanations, stopping mid-sentence to weigh each word. All I could think was, "Lady, I get it."

I have been her before, to some degree. This is how insidious racism has become. It has colored the air we breathe. It hangs in the air between the best of us. And I am not immune. But it didn't stop my cheeks from burning. It didn't stop me from forming a long string of words I wanted so badly to level at her. It didn't stop me from sitting there silently, far more graciously than my son deserved, defaulting to the avoidance of conflict and knowing full well that there was nothing I could do to shame her into greater awareness.

For the rest of the day and the days that followed, questions spun on a loop. Would she have circled the block to warn me if Robert and his friend had been white? More middle class looking? Would she have bothered to stop if my house was a little rougher around the edges, like so many of the houses in my neighborhood?

The truth became unavoidable. The guys caught their attention because they were two black men with rippling biceps, locs in their hair, and sagging pants. They dared to run into a pristine, middle-class looking home, then run back out. They didn't fit the frame. They didn't fit her ideal of "safe". They didn't fit me.

My heart couldn't help but take it further.

What would have happened if she had called the police? They'd have seen two men fitting her description running through the streets. What would Robert have done? He has always complied in the past, even when he knew he hadn't done anything wrong. But he was already late to his probation meeting, that day. His neck was already on the line. He was almost there. His PO would help him explain. That's the logic I imagined him constructing. What if he'd kept on running?

My heart stopped cold. What if?

I'm not sure running is safe for a black man anymore, or even a black boy. I'm not so sure it ever was. Yesterday a neighbor sat on my front steps reading a comic book while he waited for me. Just as I pulled up, an officer crept by, coasting more than driving.

I nodded toward the cruiser, "What's going on up there?"

"I don't know," he shrugged. "He keeps driving by, looking at me."


Later that day, Robert stopped by, just as he had promised. "Mom?" he asked, "what do you think the neighbors think of me?"

He had no clue about the confrontation with the woman in the Jeep. In four years, he has never asked a question like this.

I told him the truth. He's a grown man raising boys of his own. He needed to know.

"It don't surprise me," he shook his head and laughed. Sometimes, in an unfair world, laughter carries the frequency of pain. Some boys learn it's their safest response. "It's like all the sudden, I'm noticing the way people look at me."

My son is under the thumb of an oppressive, messed-up system because of a mistake he made over five years ago. I will go to my grave believing I wouldn't have been punished in the same way for the same crime. But he still has two years to go. And he'd better be perfect between now and then, because people are watching. They're watching his hair, and his clothes. They're watching him drive. They're watching his skin. They're watching him run.


A year ago, I set out to pay closer attention to my world. At first, I thought I was just walking my kids to school. But those trips up my street and back down turned into a condensed sort of weekday church, and then they turned me inside-out. Rooted in my unique place, I noticed the boy on the bike, and the one walking around in the middle of the day when he should have been in school. My heart grew heavier, quieter, fiercer. I began to care about different things, read different books, listen in a different way.

I watched as my oldest son became anxious, always teetering on the razor-thin line between proving everyone wrong and breaking under the weight of the pressure.

I listened as my two youngest sons unpacked sad stories of schoolyard bullies, one of them believing along the way that he is "ugly" and "looks funny," the other growing quieter every day.

I thought I might write all of this down, for me, for Robert, for the lady in the Jeep. For you. I thought I might draw parallels to the all-familiar headlines flashing across our screens, each of us choosing sides before the last word loops back to the first.

Instead, I picked up this book and devoured it in two days. I fell into the story, only in my version, Khalil was six foot four and calls me Mom. And in my version, Starr was a young man with tired eyes, code-switching between the world he's always known and the one that exists between these four walls.

A few days later, Jordan Edwards was murdered, and it felt like deja vu.

So, here I am, writing this down, believing all of it matters.
We can waste our time if we want to, trying to decide if Robert is Khalil, or if he's Jordan.

The truth is, he's neither.
The truth is, he's both.

He's my beloved son who makes me proud every day.
He can run into my house whenever he wants to.

He never has to knock.


  1. I get what you're saying. Before reading "The New Jim Crow" I would have been skeptical. I might have argued that the lady in the jeep just worried at the way they were running, or just mentioned their race because she assumed they weren't your relatives. But I see it differently now. As much as I hate to think I could be racist in any way, what you experienced is proof--we've been brainwashed whether we know it or not.

  2. Thank you, Shannan. This is important and so clearly told.

  3. This absolutely rips my heart out and I just want to come and hug you and all of your kids and make sure they know that all of the world isn't like that.... and it breaks my heart that the world is like that... thank you for sharing

  4. I kept thinking about a post on our neighborhood FB page last week. Someone asked about a man in a black jeep who was "tampering" with mailboxes. It was our mailman who sometimes (for whatever reason) has to drive his own vehicle...and has been for months. I wondered had he been white if anyone would have noticed. Thankfully, folks who saw the post before me, nipped it in the bud!

  5. Well, this did me in for the day. Cried like a baby. I've got sleeping littles who are grieving and struggling something hard and trying to attach and bond and this was my quiet moment for the day. And a good choice indeed. So well said Shannan. Thank you for using your greatest weapon. (Loved The Hate U Give)

  6. Bless your heart. I'm keeping Robert in my prayers.

  7. I just want to hug you all - what a beautiful testament to unconditional love - just like Jesus.

  8. This comment has been removed by the author.

  9. My 7 year old son is mixed with darker features and has just begun to understand how the color of someone's skin can change their reality. He insisted that his hair is dark brown like mine and my husband's, (his new,Grace-given-Christ-loving-Mexican-Father by choice) instead of black. He told me he would rather look Mexican, because people with darker skin don't get treated as well sometimes. And now I wonder if even a Latin heritage is any safer in this climate... It's my prayer to walk the line of being aware and not paranoid, of acknowledging his feelings and teaching him the truth; that we are strangers in this broken world, and that his identity is not found in his color, ethnicity, or family, but in his faith. And we will all face hardships, some of us more than others, but the Lord is honored when we persevere in faith.
    Thank you for writing with such honesty and loving so fiercy. Robert is blessed with a momma like you.
    His by Grace, Steph

    1. Praise the Lord for this truth that our identity is not in the clothes we wear, the home we live in, what color our father is (or even if we have one for that matter.) I know it sounds trite but maybe that's b/c we have made it that way: Christ alone is who defines us, gives us purpose, and frees us from feeling less than even when people want to do otherwise (wheather it's purposeful or not.) What a beautiful truth to share with your son. His skin is apart of who he is but does not make him what he is. Only Christ can do this.

  10. I hate this. I love my oldest grandson so much. Just last night me and Gramps was bragging on him to some old friends at a restaurant. They asked if he has been to our home, we told them no, but we are counting the days until he can run into his grandparents house (without knocking). What I hate the most is how I used to be just like the lady that stopped by trying to connect the dots that really don't connect. Give him a hug for Gram.

  11. Excellent as always, I'll think on this for days and constantly compare myself to her. But Shannon, what do you mean ROBERT HAS SONS!?! You've never talked about being a grandma or showed photos. I'm so confused PLEASE explain lol.

  12. What an important post! Thank you for writing it so honestly and eloquently. We have so far to go. Help us, Lord!

  13. Shannan. My goodness. I'm in tears. Your son. What that must feel like as a mama to see the way this world sees him, but yet to know who he really is. I just feel my mama heart breaking. Much love to all of you. And let's keep making this world better, all of us, in any way we can.

  14. Wow. So beautifully written. Thank you for sharing your life and experience with us all. A lot to think about today.

  15. You are doing important work sharing these stories. Black Lives do matter.

  16. Thank you for sharing your ugly truth! I love you and I love Robert!

  17. This post was shared on a list of Mother's Day reads from Emily Freeman and from the title I thought it would be a story of teaching small children to walk, in a quaint nostalgic sort of way. Nope. The ugly sting of racism, and the palatable fear you all live with. This story was Im sure so hard to write, thank you for speaking the truth so we may see differently and not be dismissive of uncomfortable truths.

  18. Thank you for being willing to tell your stories, because they matter. You speak as a mom of children of color, and people are reading. Isn't it sad that we have to relate to you as a person before we are willing to listen? Hate it.

  19. Thank you! My little brother is brown and came out to visit us in NY last week. The way he had to look over his shoulder role my heart.

  20. I know you're right about the racism aspect of this, but it happens to white young men too. When my daughter was dating my now son in law, he was living a bit on the edge. He was adopted and then thrown out to live on his own at 18 and had no family to lean on. A few traffic stops and a tickets for driving after letting his insurance lapse added up to fines too much for him to be able to pay and he ended up being arrested in an nearby very white suburb driving his old junky car. I'm thankful we were able to be there for him and help him get his fines paid. It's awful how the system is set up to be so expensive that its almost impossible to find a way out for a young person without help. He and my daughter have been married for four years now and he's a hard worker and a great husband.

  21. I can relate with so much of this Shannon. I'm interracial married soon to have our third child. Since I've been married I've experienced so much of this that I never saw before or maybe just never noticed before. It does bother my husband but he doesn't seem to struggle with it as much as I do. Can sorta laugh it off like that. Really appreciate the way you shared this so honestly and graciously. I so often want to share more but it's so hard to talk about, thanks for your words.

  22. Shannon, this post has really gotten to me....and I know I am changing. Trying to examine my prejudices. They come from fear of the unknown. So I need to KNOW more. Thank you!!!
    A year or so ago I read a book about the lack of justice for blacks in the criminal justice system and a young attorney who founded an organization to represent them, especially blacks on death row. I know you have featured the book here on your blog. I can't recall the title or author (Brian?). Can you refresh my memory? I want to select this book for my book club to read.
    Thanks, Shannon!


  23. Congratulations to all of the participants of this program. mayo international I bet they learned a lot from the project. This will help me for a school project. Keep the posts coming.

  24. I at that point needed to give the class to the scholarly facilitator. I was given the book the foundation utilized and advised which pages to take a gander at for material. That the ed closure of the past tense had three unique sounds was totally new to me, despite the fact that I utilized the right sounds each time instinctually. Study Russian in Kiev